Переговоры по Украине: стоит ли им верить (эфир Press TV)
Источник: https://www.ryandawson.org/p/ukraine-talks-even-worth-it-or-just
Краткое содержание
Запись эфира Press TV, в котором ведущий обсуждает с корреспондентом Мариной Куртиновой из Москвы и аналитиком Райаном Доусоном (на связи из Сеула) предстоящий раунд переговоров по Украине. Вступление: Москва не получала от Европы идей по гарантиям безопасности, но без участия Европы обсуждение безопасности между Россией и Украиной в какой-то момент станет невозможным; стороны обменялись новыми ударами, Россия била по энергетической инфраструктуре Украины, сильнее всего пострадал Киевский регион. Текст дан в двух вариантах расшифровки (черновой и более чистой), содержание совпадает.
Позиция Москвы по переговорам
Куртинова сообщает, что Путин обсудил с Совбезом России предстоящие переговоры, назначенные на следующий вторник в Абу-Даби. В российскую делегацию, по её словам, входят замминистра иностранных дел Сергей Рыбков и Михаил Галузин, а также представители двух управлений Генштаба Игорь Пестуков и Юрий Жиголовский. Украина, как стало известно, намерена обсуждать энергетическое перемирие и привлечь аграрных экспертов, чтобы выяснить готовность Москвы к таким договорённостям; Киев настаивает на учёте позиции европейских стран при обсуждении будущей архитектуры безопасности и гарантий. Перед раундом украинская сторона консультировалась с американскими и европейскими партнёрами в Брюсселе. Куртинова сравнивает подготовку переговоров с предпроизводством сериала: у сторон нет согласованных целей. Россия, по её оценке, действует открыто и стремится к безопасности, торговле и технологическим связям, тогда как США и Европа, по её утверждению, преследуют единственную цель, враждебную России, и не заинтересованы ни в мире, ни в торговле (это позиция российской стороны, а не установленный факт).
Комментарий Райана Доусона
Ведущий замечает, что и Москва, и Киев хотят гарантий от Запада, хотя прежние обещания (нерасширение НАТО на восток для России, гарантии в обмен на отказ от ядерного оружия для Украины) не были выполнены, и спрашивает, зачем снова им верить. Доусон соглашается и приводит пример: Зеленский выдвигает невыполнимые условия по прекращению ударов по энергетике (месяц без ударов в обмен на месячный запас ракет Patriot, которых, по словам Доусона, у США нет, поскольку они израсходованы в «бессмысленной войне с Ираном» и на защиту Израиля), а также требует ещё 16 млрд долларов, обещанных с 2024 года, при том что получил свыше 30 млрд от Великобритании и свыше 196 млрд от США (цифры названы Доусоном и в эфире не проверялись). Прецедентов честных переговоров, по его мнению, нет, шансы очень малы, и это «пустые слова», война продолжится. Тем не менее отказ от разговоров он считает проигрышем по определению.
Кто выигрывает от затягивания войны
На вопрос ведущего, зачем Запад позволяет Украине «истекать кровью», не давая ни мира, ни достаточного оружия, Доусон отвечает, что главная слабость Украины не в технике, а в людях: мобилизация принудительная, страна «исчерпывает» личный состав (он упоминает «пыточные камеры» — тезис без доказательств в эфире). Вопрос, по его мнению, исходит из ложной предпосылки, будто инициаторы войны заботятся об интересах Украины: продолжение войны выгодно тем, кто зарабатывает на поставках и помощи, а «Зеленскому нужен седьмой дом» — то есть это личный коммерческий интерес, а не национальный.
Значимость
Эфир в российском государственно-ориентированном формате иллюстрирует рамку, в которой Доусон оценивает переговоры: скептицизм к Западу и Киеву, оправдание российской позиции. Многие утверждения (о коррупции, ракетах, размерах помощи) даны без источников и требуют проверки.
🧾 Транскрипт (формат)
Ukraine talks even worth it? Or just more lies
Источник: https://www.ryandawson.org/p/ukraine-talks-even-worth-it-or-just
He said that Moscow has received no ideas from Europe on security guarantees, but added that any discussion of security between Russia and Ukraine will be impossible at some point without Europe's involvement. This comes as the two sides have exchanged fresh fire. Russia targeted Ukraine's energy infrastructure. The Kyiv region was hardest hit. Joining us for our program is Marina Kurtanova, our Press TV colleague out of Moscow, and Ryan Dawson, geopolitical analyst, joining us from Seoul. Hello to both of you. Marina, we're going to start with you to get the latest. Obviously, give us a breakdown of what this is all about, and does it, in essence, differ from the last time we heard about sit-downs and hashing out of a peace deal?
Good afternoon, dear colleagues. So, as you mentioned before, Russian President Putin discussed the upcoming intellectual talks on resolving the conflict in Ukraine set to take place next Tuesday in Abu Dhabi with the members of the Russian Security Council. So, he noted that ahead of the negotiations, he had invited the colleagues who will be participating in them to the meeting, and he proposed a brief discussion on the subject. Delegation to the upcoming talks in Abu Dhabi on resolving the conflict in Ukraine will include Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Rybkov and Mikhail Galuzin, as well as representatives from two directorates of the General Staff of the Russian Armed Forces, Igor Pestukov and Yuri Zhigolovsky. As for Ukraine, it became known that plans to discuss an energy ceasefire and agricultural experts to determine whether Moscow is ready for such agreements. It is understood in Moscow that the Ukrainian side has pointed to the need to take into account the positions of European countries when discussing the future security architecture and guarantees for Ukraine.
Ahead of a new round of negotiations, the Ukrainian side held consultations with its American and European partners in Brussels. What is happening right now? The preparation for and active discussion of future negotiations between Russia, Ukraine, and the United States, frankly, here in Moscow resembles the pre-production of a film or a new episode. The negotiations parties have no alignment whatsoever regarding their goals. Russia approaches the engagement openly, its position exposed and ready for interaction. It seeks security for all trade, technology, and the development of ties. the negation of life for Russia. That is their gain. They have no interest in peace or trade, what they can do else? Unlimited cost -free resources to sustain them through the two difficult decades of artificially engineered turbulence that are inevitably approaching.
Marina, we don't have a lot of time because we kind of got into Our news review a little bit late. We only have a couple minutes. I really want to get Ryan Dawson in on the conversation. Ryan, good to have you, bud. Okay, so obviously they both want guarantees, especially from the Europeans, both Moscow and Kiev. And it's funny because Moscow's got guarantees in the past, no more eastward expansion. And also Kiev's got guarantees that if they give up what is the mass destruction that will be taken care of both have been by the West and those promises have both fallen flat on their faces. So why even look to the West for promises or guarantees at this point?
Well, she was right in what she's saying. And if you listen to President Zelensky, for example, he's putting unmeetable conditions on preventing drone strikes on energy infrastructure, for example. He said, if you want a month without strikes on energy infrastructure, then give us a month worth of Patriot missiles, meaning anti-polistic missiles, which the United States doesn't have. They ate them up on the pointless war on Iran. And protecting Israel. And he says he wants another $16 billion that was promised but hasn't been delivered all the way back from 2024. But he's gotten over $30 billion from the UK and over $196 billion from the United States and is still whining about more money. So it doesn't seem there's good precedent for negotiations to be truthful. All prudence would tell you in the past that they say one
And Ryan do you gauge this being at this point any different this round of possible putting this thing asleep since what early 2022 or do you just think it's going to be another futile round in a long protracted war?
It's never futile because it's automatically, you forfeit if you don't even talk, but the odds are very low. I see this more, nothing but hot air and the war will continue. This is going to be settled emotionally.
Ryan, when you see that, all you're really doing is bleeding out Ukraine. Ukraine, regardless, maybe they don't want to give it the level of sophisticated weaponry that it needs to really be in this fight. Not that it's not, but it doesn't seem anywhere remotely close to being equipped to the point where it would come out of victorious. On top of Russian forces. So what is the point in bleeding? If this is really your ally in Kiev, why let it bleed out slowly like this? Why not take the impetus to either end this thing or give it the kind of level of grade weaponry it needs to possibly have a chance at winning? Because they're just helping it bleed out and lose slowly at this point.
Yeah, and the gap isn't even in the weaponry so much as it is in the number of personnel. The real weak point for Ukraine is they're running out of men. They're trying to press people into service. They have their torture chambers. They're going to run out of people. But what you're asking assumes they have the interests of Ukraine at heart. Are the people pushing for the continuation of this war, the ones profiteering from the selling and the aid? Zelensky needs a seventh house. They're the ones profiting from the war. It's not in the national interest of Ukraine. It's in the personal, commercial interest of the people pushing for the war.
All right. Thank you to those who are joining us from Moscow. Mr. Ryan Dawson joining us from Seoul. ...Segment of your presidency news.
════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ ═══ Транскрипция видео ═══ ════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
═══ Транскрипция видео 1 ═══
The Moscow's received no ideas from Europe on security guarantees, but added that any discussion of security between Russia and Ukraine will be impossible at some point without Europe's involvement. This comes as the two sides of exchange, fresh fire. Russia targeted Ukraine's energy infrastructure. The Kiev region was hardest hit. Joining us for our program is Marina Kurtinova, our press TV colleague out of Moscow, and Ryan Dawson, geopolitical analyst, joining us from Seoul. Hello to both of you. Marina, we're going to start with you to get the latest. Obviously, give us a breakdown of what this is all about and does it, in essence, differ from the last time we heard about sit-downs and possible hashing out of a peace deal. So, as you mentioned before, Russian President Putin discussed the upcoming presidential talks on resolving the conflict in Ukraine set to take place next Tuesday in Abu Dhabi with the members of the Russian Security Council. So, he noted that ahead of the negotiations, he had invited the colleagues who will be participating in them to the meeting, and he proposed a brief discussion on the subject. As for Ukraine, it became known that plans to discuss an energy ceasefire and agricultural experts to determine whether Moscow is ready for such agreements. It is understood in Moscow that the Ukrainian side has pointed to the need to take into account the positions of European countries when discussing the future security architecture and guarantees for Ukraine. Ahead of a new round of negotiations, the Ukrainian side held consultations with its American and European partners in Brussels. What is happening right now, the preparation for and active discussion of future negotiations between Russia, Ukraine, and the United States, frankly, here in Moscow resembles the pre-production of a film or a new episode in a television series. The negotiating parties have no alignment whatsoever regarding their goals. Russia approaches the engagement openly, its position exposed and ready for interaction. It seeks security for all trade, technology, and the development of ties. The United States and Europe, at their core, they share a single objective, the negation of life for Russia. That is their game. They have no interest in peace or trade. What do you think, anything else? Unlimited, cost-free resources to sustain them through the two difficult decades of artificially engineered turbulence that are inevitably approaching... Marina, we don't have a lot of time because we kind of got into our news review a little bit late. We only have a couple minutes. I really want to get Ryan Dawson in on the conversation. Ryan, good to have you, bud. Okay, so obviously they both want guarantees, especially from the Europeans, both Moscow and Kiev. And it's funny because Moscow's got guarantees in the past, no more eastward expansion. And also, Kiev's got guarantees that if they give up weapons of mass destruction, that there will be taken care of both have been by the West. And those promises have both fallen flat on their faces. So why even look to the West for promises or guarantees at this point? Well, she was right in what she's saying. And if you listen to President Zelensky, for example, he's putting unmeetable conditions on preventing drone strikes on energy infrastructure, for example. He said if you want a month without strikes on energy infrastructure, then give us a month's worth of Patriot missiles, meaning anti- ballistic missiles, which the United States doesn't have. They ate them up on a pointless war on Iran and protecting Israel. And he says he wants another $16 billion that was promised but hasn't been delivered all the way back from 2024. But he's gotten over $30 billion from the UK and over $196 billion from the United States and is still whining about more money. So, you know, it doesn't seem there's good precedent for negotiations to be truthful. And Ryan, do you gauge this being, at this point, any different, this round of possible putting this thing asleep since, what, early 2022? Or do you just think it's going to be another futile round in a long protracted war? It's never futile because it's automatically, you forfeit if you don't even talk. But the odds are very low. I see this more, nothing but hot air and the war will continue. This is going to be settled on nationally.
And Ryan, when you see that all you're really doing is bleeding out Ukraine, Ukraine, regardless, maybe they don't want to give it the level of sophisticated weaponry that it needs to really be in this fight. Not that it's not, but it doesn't seem anywhere remotely close to being equipped to the point where it will come out of victorious on top of Russian forces. So what is the point in bleeding? If this is really your ally in Kiev, why let it bleed out slowly like this? Why not take the impetus to either end this thing or give it the kind of level of grade weaponry it needs to possibly have a chance of winning? Because they're just helping it bleed out and lose slowly at this point. Yeah. And the gap isn't even in the weaponry so much as it is in the number of personnel. The real weak point for Ukraine is they're running out of men. They're trying to press people into service. They have their torture chambers. They're going to run out of people. What you're asking assumes they have the interests of Ukraine at heart. Are the people pushing for the continuation of this war, the ones profiteering from the selling and the aid? And, you know, Zelensky needs a seventh house. They're the ones profiting from the war. It's not in the national interest of Ukraine. It's in the personal commercial interest of the people pushing for the war. All right, thank you for joining us from Moscow. I'm Mr.
Ryan Dawson joining us from Seoul. This is a segment of your presidency news.